Sunday, November 21, 2010

Rachel Carson and her Ecological Genocide

Over a hundred million African people have died since 1972 as a direct result of the malaria virus. Why the sudden jump in malaria? Rachel Carson's 1972 novel Silent Spring was a bestseller, detailing the harmful environmental effects of using the pesticide DDT, which had practically eliminated malaria. However, after her book sparked the environmentalist movement that caused the banning of DDT. Without this cheap, effective pesticide, millions of Africans have now lost their lives to the increase in malaria, and typhus as well. Dr. Wenceslaus Kilama, Malaria Foundation International Chairman has said it is "like loading up Boeing 747 airlines each day and deliberately crashing them into Mt. Kilimanjaro". The resurgence of diseases that were eradicated 50 years ago, and are now worse than ever, is a major point of concern. Former Surgeon General and retired U.S. Navy Vice Admiral Dr. Harold M. Koenig stated that when used correctly, DDT can in fact be safe for humans and for the environment. 
It turns out, DDT is not as harmful to the environment as Carson claimed it was in her book. According to tests conducted by Dr. Philip Butler, the director of the Fish and Wildlife Service's Sabine Island Research Laboratory, "92 percent of DDT and its metabolites disappear from the environment after 38 days".  Testing has also concluded that "DDT is so safe that no symptoms have been observed among the 130,000 spraymen or the 535 million inhabitants of sprayed houses [over the past 29 years of its existence]. No toxicity was observed in the wildlife of the countries participating in the malaria campaign." 
The only reason that so many lives are being lost to these infectious diseases today is because of Carson and her predictions that DDT would eventually wipe out the human race through causing cancer in the population. Carson came to this conclusion by arguing that the rise in cancer rates from 1940-1960 was proof that DDT was the cause because spraying began in 1940 and continued. However, when looking at the Center for Disease Control data from the 1900-1960,her theory is way off the mark because cancer rates started to skyrocket in direct correlation to a surge of tobacco use. Yet, despite Carson's research inconsistencies and dearth of solid scientific evidence, DDT was eventually banned in the U.S.
If Carson's modern day crusaders are really concerned about saving lives and helping developing countries, then must allow DDT to be used without repercussions.